Non-territorial Autonomy in East-Central Europe: What About Romania?
Abstract
The paper attempts to provide an understanding of the reasons Romania has not sought non-territorial autonomy as a solution for minority claims by analysing a 15-year-old legislative proposal elaborated by a minority rights organisation. Although the analysis of this antiquated proposal seems long overdue, it holds answers relating to the attitude of the State and of minority organisations regarding autonomy, in which—ultimately—the issue seems to be a lack of serious intention by either of the two to change the minority legal status quo.
References
Act CLXXIX of 2011 on the rights of nationalities (Hungary)
Andreescu, G. (2001) Ruleta - Români și maghiari, 1990-2000 - Jurnal Tematic, Iași: Editura Polirom
Approval (aviz, in Romanian) of the Legislative Council no. 575/23.05.2005. http://www.cdep.ro/proiecte/2005/500/00/2/cl502.pdf (Accessed 06.07.2020)
Bakk, M. (2004) 'Az autonómia-tervek két szakasza Erdélyben 1989 után', Magyar Kisebbség 9(1-2)
Barbieri, S. (2014) 'National-Cultural Autonomy in the Russian Federation: The Case of the Tomsk Oblast', in Salat, L., Constantin, S., Osipov, A, Székely, I. G. (eds.) (2014) Autonomy Arrangements around the World: A Collection of Well and Lesser Known Cases, Cluj-Napoca: Editura Institutului pentru Studierea Problemelor Minorităților Naționale
Benedikter, T. (2011) 'What is political autonomy about? Fundamental features of regional territorial autonomy' in Benedikter, T. (ed.) (2011) Solving Ethnic Conflict through Self-Government - A short guide to autonomy in Europe and South Asia, Bolzano: EURAC
Bognár, Z. (2006) 'Romániai magyar autonómiakoncepciók. Az 1989 és 2006 között kidolgozott törvénytervezetek', in Ludassy, M., Bognár, Z., Egry, G., Salat, L., Fejtő, F. (eds.) (2006) Autonómia, liberalizmus, szociáldemokrácia. Fejtő Ferenc, Salat Levente, Ludassy Mária, Egry Gábor és Bognár Zoltán írásai, Budapest: Európai Összehasonlító Kisebbségkutatások Közalapítvány
Brunner, G., Küpper, G., 'European Options of Autonomy', in Gál, K. (ed.) (2002), Minority Governance in Europe, Budapest: LGI-ECMI, p. 19. cited by Vizi, B. (2014) 'Does European Integration Support the Minority Quest for Autonomy? Minority Claims for Self-Government and Devolution Processes in Europe' in Kántor, Z. (ed.), Autonomies in Europe: Solutions and Challenges, Budapest: L'Harmattan
Ciobanu, V. (2010) 'Proiecte pentru o lege a minorităților naționale în România interbelică', in Gidó, A., Horváth, I., Pál, J. (eds.) (2010), 140 de ani de legislație minoritară în Europa Centrală și de Est, Cluj-Napoca: Editura ISPMN, Kriterion
Comments of the Government of Romania on the Fourth Opinion of the Advisory Committee on the implementation of the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities by Romania: GVT/COM/IV(2018)001
Decker, D. C. (2007) 'The Use of Cultural Autonomy to Prevent Conflict and Meet the Copenhagen Criteria: The Case of Romania', Ethnopolitics, 6:3, https://doi.org/10.1080/17449050701487454
Document ACFC/31DOC(2008)001, available here: https://rm.coe.int/16800bc7e8 (Accessed 05.07.2020)
Donders, Y. (2008) 'The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples - A Victory for Cultural Autonomy?' in Boerefijn, I., Goldschmidt, J. (eds.) (2008), Changing Perceptions of Sovereignty and Human Rights: Essays in Honour of Cees Flinterman, Antwerp: Intersentia, cited by Yupsanis, A. (2014) 'Autonomy for Minorities: Definitions, Types and Status in International Law', Finnish Yearbook of International Law, Vol. 25.
Draft legislative proposal on the statute of national minorities in Romania: http://www.cdep.ro/proiecte/2005/500/00/2/pl502.pdf (Accessed 06.07.2020)
Fink, C. (1996) 'The Paris Peace Conference and the Question of Minority Rights', Peace & Change, Vol. 21 No. 3 https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0130.1996.tb00272.x
Fisch, J., Mage, A. (2015) The Right of Self-Determination of Peoples - The Domestication of an Illusion. Cambridge University Press, https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9781139805698.
Framework convention on the protection of national minorities
Gaftoescu, V. I. (1939) Poziții juridice în dreptul internațional - Problema minorităților, București: Imprimeriile "Curentul" SA.
Humphrey, J. P. (1973) 'The International Law of Human Rights in the Middle Twentieth Century', in Bos, M. (1973) The Present State of International Law and Other Essays written in honour of the Centenary Celebration of the International Law Association 1873-1973, Deventer: Kluwer - The Netherlands https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-4497-3_6
Jászi, O. (1918) A Monarchia jövője: a dualizmus bukása és a Dunai Egyesült Államok, Available at: http://mek.oszk.hu/02200/02222/02222.pdf (Accessed 06.07.2020)
Kiss, T., Toró, T., Székely, I. G. (2018) 'Unequal Accommodation: An Institutionalist Analysis of Ethnic Claim-Making and Bargaining', in Kiss, T., Székely, I. G., Toró, T., Bárdi, N., Horváth, I. (eds.) (2018) Unequal Accommodation of Minority Rights - Hungarians in Transylvania, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-78893-7_3.
Kovács, P. (2012) 'Az autonómia és a nemzetközi jog', International Relations Quarterly, year III., no. 2
Kymlicka, W. (2008) 'The Evolving Basis of European Norms of Minority Rights: Rights to Culture, Participation and Autonomy', in Weller, M., Blacklock, D., Nobbs, K. (eds.) (2008), The Protection of Minorities in the Wider Europe, London: Palgrave Macmillan, https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230582293_2.
Law on cultural autonomy for national minorities (Estonia)
Law on the national councils of national minorities (Serbia)
Malloy, T. H. (2015) 'Introduction - 3. Defining NTA' in Malloy, T. H., Osipov, A., Vizi, B. (eds.) (2015) Managing Diversity Through Non-Territorial Autonomy. Oxford University Press, https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198738459.003.0001.
Marinkás, Gy. (2018) Az őslakos népek védelmének aktuális jogi kihívásai, Miskolc: Miskolci Egyetem Állam és Jogtudományi Kar
Nagy, L. (1944) A kisebbségek alkotmányjogi helyzete Nagyromániában, Kolozsvár: Minerva Irodalmi és Nyomdai Műintézet R.T.
Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe - The Lund Recommendations on the Effective Participation of National Minorities in Public Life & Explanatory Note, 1999
Pepine, H. (2010) 'Autonomia culturală', Deutsche Welle, 02.02.2010. https://www. dw.com/ro/autonomia-cultural%C4%83/a-5203867 (Accessed: 06.07.2020)
Renner, K. (2005) 'Nation and State' a translation in and by Nimni, E. (ed.) (2005) National Cultural Autonomy and Its Contemporary Critics, London: Routledge
Russian law on national-cultural autonomy http://www.regione.taa.it/biblioteca/ minoranze/russia3.pdf (Accessed 06.07.2020)
Salat, L. (2014) 'The Chances of Ethnic Autonomy in Romania - Between Theory and Practice', in Kántor, Z. (ed.) (2014) Autonomies in Europe: Solutions and Challenges, Budapest: L'Harmattan
Smith, D. (2012) Ethnic Diversity and the Nation State, New York: Routledge, https://doi. org/10.4324/9780203118320.
Smith, D. J. (2014), 'Minority Territorial and Non-Territorial Autonomy in Europe: Theoretical Perspectives and Practical Challenges', in Kántor, Z. (ed.) (2014), Autonomies in Europe: Solutions and Challenges, Budapest: L'Harmattan
Smith, D. J., 'National-Cultural Autonomy in Contemporary Estonia', in Salat, L., Constantin, S., Osipov, A, Székely, I. G. (eds.) (2014) Autonomy Arrangements around the World: A Collection of Well and Lesser Known Cases, Cluj-Napoca: Editura Institutului pentru Studierea Problemelor Minorităților Naționale
Stroschein, S. (2015) 'Reconfiguring State-Minority Negotiations for Better Outcomes', in T. H., Osipov, A., Vizi, B. (eds.) (2015) Managing Diversity Through Non-Territorial Autonomy, Oxford University Press, https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof: oso/9780198738459.003.0002.
Turda, M. (2001) 'Transylvania Revisited: Public Discourse and Historical Representation in Contemporary Romania', in Trencsényi, B., Petrescu, D., Petrescu, C., Iordachi, C., Kántor, Z. (2001) Nation-Building and Contested Identities: Romanian and Hungarian Case Studies, Budapest: Regio Books, Iași: Editura Polirom
Varga, A. (2010) 'Sistemul drepturilor minoritare şi autonomia culturală în proiectul de lege privind statutul minorităţilor naţionale', in Gidó, A., Horváth, I., Pál, J. (eds.) (2010), 140 de ani de legislație minoritară în Europa Centrală și de Est, Cluj-Napoca: Editura ISPMN, Kriterion
Vizi, B. (2014) 'Does European Integration Support the Minority Quest for Autonomy? Minority Claims for Self-Government and Devolution Processes in Europe' in Kántor, Z. (ed.), Autonomies in Europe: Solutions and Challenges, Budapest: L'Harmattan
Vizi, B. (2015) 'Minority Self-Governments in Hungary - a Special Model of NTA?', in T. H., Osipov, A., Vizi, B. (eds.) (2015) Managing Diversity Through NonTerritorial Autonomy, Oxford University Press, https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof: oso/9780198738459.003.0003.
Wong, M. (2013) 'Reclaiming Identity: Rethinking Non-Territorial Autonomy', Journal on Ethnopolitics and Minority Issues in Europe, vol. 12, no. 1
Yupsanis, A. (2016) 'Cultural autonomy for minorities in the Baltic States, Ukraine and The Russian Federation: a dead letter', XXXVI Polish Yearbook of International Law
Zahorán, Cs. (2010) 'O mică Ungarie în România Mare. Alternative pentru Secuime în proiectele maghiare dintre cele două războaie mondiale', in Gidó, A., Horváth,
I., Pál, J. (eds.) (2010), 140 de ani de legislație minoritară în Europa Centrală și de Est, Cluj-Napoca: Editura ISPMN, Kriterion.
