The Relationship of the Croatian Constitutional Court and Supreme Court to the Court of Justice of the European Union in National Case Law

Lucija Sokanović

doi:10.47078/2023.2.295-316

Lucija Sokanović Associate Professor, University of Split, Faculty of Law https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4274-7789

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47078/2023.2.295-316

Keywords: Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia, Supreme Court, CJEU, preliminary questions, ultra vires

Abstract

After a short introduction to Croatia’s accession to the EU, this paper deals with the obligations for national courts arising from EU membership in a historical overview and the current state. Furthermore, the relationship between the Croatian Constitutional Court, the Croatian Supreme Court, and the Court of Justice of the European Union in national case law is analysed. In addition, the hierarchy of national and EU laws is questioned, as is the notion of constitutional identity. The relationship between the national constitutional courts of the EU member states, the national Supreme Court, and the CJEU is not conceived as a relation of subordination, but of communication and dialogue, the ultimate goal of which is the harmonisation of the acquis of the EU member states and legal security for all its citizens, while at the same time respecting the specificities of each member state.

References

Bačić, P. (2012) ‘On the Rule of Law in Croatia and the Role of the Constitutional Court’ in Heintze, H. J. (ed.) Summer Academy “Rule of Law, Human Rights and European Union” - Book of Proceedings. Skopje, Macedónia: Centre for South East European Law School Network (SEELS), pp. 67–95.

Bačić, P., Sarić, I. (2014) ‘Short Study of Activism through the European Court of Justice Cases on Freedom of Movement for Workers’, Collected Papers of Split Law Faculty, 51(1), pp. 27–44. [Online]. Available at: https://hrcak.srce.hr/en/file/171973 (Accessed: 30 June 2023).

Barić, S., Bačić, P. (2010) ‘Croatia: Constitutional Courts as Positive Legislators’ in Brewer-Carías, A. R. (ed.) Constitutional Courts as Positive Legislators: A Comparative Law Study. New York: Cambridge University Press, pp. 407–444; https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511994760.018.

Blagojević, A. (2017) ‘Procedures Regarding National Identity Clause in the National Constitutional Court’s and the CJEU’s Case-law’ in Duić, D., Petrašević, T. (eds.) Procedural Aspects of EU Law, EU and Comparative Law Issues and Challenges Series (ECLIC). Faculty of Law, Josip Juraj Strossmayer University of Osijek, pp. 210–237. https://doi.org/10.25234/eclic/6529.

Burazin, L., Gardašević, Đ. (2021) ‘Constitutionalization of the Croatian Legal Order’, Collected Papers of Zagreb Law Faculty, 71(2), pp. 221–254; https://doi.org/10.3935/zpfz.71.2.04.

Ćapeta, T. (2015) ‘Criminal Courts and Cooperation with the EU Court of Justice in preliminary Ruling Procedures’, Croatian Annual for Criminal Law and Practice, 22(1), pp. 49–66 [Online]. Available at: https://hrcak.srce.hr/155516 (Accessed: 20 June 2023).

Derenčinović, D. (2014) ‘The Scope of Verification of Double Criminality Referred to in the Act on Judicial Cooperation in Criminal Matters with EU Member States’, Croatian Annual for Criminal Law and Practice, 21(2), pp. 247–270 [Online]. Available at: https://hrcak.srce.hr/143580 (Accessed: 20 June 2023).

Horvat Vuković, A. (2019a) ‘“Master of One's Own Body”: The European Compound Republic and Scrutiny of ultra vires Activities of EU Bodies’, Zagreb Law Review, 8(2), pp. 77–94 [Online]. Available at: https://hrcak.srce.hr/240718 (Accessed: 20 June 2023).

Horvat Vuković, A. (2019b) ‘The Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia as a ‘European’ Court and the Preservation of National Standards of Fundamental Rights Protection’, Collected Papers of Zagreb Law Faculty, 69(2), pp. 249–276; https://doi.org/10.3935/zpfz.69.2.04.

Kostadinov, B. (2011) ‘Ustavni identitet i materijalna kontrola ustavnosti ustavnih promjena: Austrija, Češka, Indija, Italija i Republika Hrvatska’, Informator, 59 [Online]. Available at: https://informator.hr/strucni-clanci/ustavni-identitet-i-materijalna-kontrola-ustavnosti-ustavnih-promjena?hls= (Accessed: 20 June 2023).

Novak, S. (2020) ‘Dijalozi između ustavnih sudova država članica Europske unije i Suda Europske unije’, Pravni vjesnik, 36 (3–4), pp. 113–136; https://doi.org/10.25234/pv/10408.

Novak, S. (2022) ‘The ultra vires decisions of the EU court – The beginning of judicial conflict or cooperation’, Pravni vjesnik, 38(2), pp. 37–54; https://doi.org/10.25234/pv/20189.

Omejec, J. (2016) Study on European Constitutional Courts as the Courts of Human Rights: Assessment, Challenges, Perspectives [Online]. Available at: https://bib.irb.hr/datoteka/796420.OMEJEC_-_European_Constitutional_Courts_as_the_Courts_of_Human_Rights.pdf. (Accessed: 5 July 2023).

Petrić, D. (2023) ‘The Preliminary Ruling Procedure 2.0’, European Papers, 8(1), pp. 25–42.

Petschko, M., Capik, A. B. (2014) ‘One Says the Things Which One Feels the Need to Say, and Which the Other Will Not Understand: Slovak Pension Cases Before the CJEU and Czech Courts’, Croatian Yearbook of European Law and Policy, 2014/9, pp. 61–76; https://doi.org/10.3935/cyelp.09.2013.170.

Pítrová, L. (2013) ‘The Judgment of the Czech Constitutional Court in the “Slovak Pensions” Case and its Possible Consequences (In Light of the Fortiter in Re Suaviter in Modo Principle)’, The Lawyer Quarterly, 3(2), pp. 86¬–101 [Online]. Available at: https://tlq.ilaw.cas.cz/index.php/tlq/article/viewFile/70/57 (Accessed: 5 July 2023).

Rodin, S. (2009) ‘The relationship between the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia and the Court of Justice of the European Communities in Luxembourg after accession Republic of Croatia to full membership in the European Union’ in Barbić, J. (ed.) Croatian Constitutional Judging. Zagreb: Croatian Academy of Sciences and Arts, pp. 247–277.

Rodin, S. (2011a) ‘Pravo Europske unije i pravni poredak Republike Hrvatske nakon 20 godina hrvatskog Ustava’ in Bačić, A. (ed.) Dvadeseta obljetnica Ustava Republike Hrvatske. Zagreb: HAZU, pp. 87–118 [Online]. Available at: https://www.bib.irb.hr/513098 (Accessed: 30 June 2023).

Rodin, S. (2011b) ‘National Identity and Market Freedoms After the Treaty of Lisbon’, Croatian Yearbook of European Law and Policy, 7(1), pp. 11–41; https://doi.org/10.3935/cyelp.07.2011.130.