The Right to a Healthy Environment in the Light of the New Case Law of the Croatian Constitutional Court
Abstract
This research paper aims to investigate if notable environmental matters have, in recent years, come before the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia, in light of the increasing number of similar cases brought before the highest courts in European countries (Chapter 1). Previous analyses concerning constitutional adjudication on environmental issues have revealed that the Croatian Constitutional Court has seldom invoked Article 69 of the Constitution of the Republic of Croatia, a provision which enshrines the right to a healthy life (Chapter 2). However, on 18 April 2023, the Constitutional Court rendered a landmark judgment wherein it affirmed that the Croatian Constitution protects the citizens’ right to a healthy life and environment. The case involved a dispute over the constitutionality of the Decision on the Order and Dynamics of Landfill Closure. This paper will thoroughly examine and scrutinise this significant constitutional case (Chapter 3). To commence, the analysis shall delineate the magnitude of Croatia’s waste manage- ment deficiencies—failings which were deemed by the Constitutional Court to violate the principle of legality and the constitutional duty to comply with EU laws (Chapter 3.1). Thereafter, the study shall address the formal inconsistency of the disputed Decision with the Constitution (Chapter 3.2). Subsequent chapters shall demonstrate how the Constitu- tional Court assessed point III of the contested Decisions as an excessive (and therefore disproportionate) limitation of the fundamental right to a healthy life and environment prescribed in Article 69 of the Constitution (Chapter 3.3) and further, how it encroached upon the constitutionally safeguarded right of citizens to local and regional self-gov- ernment (Chapter 3.4). The concluding portion of this paper shall recount the process by which the Constitutional Court’s decision took place (Chapter 3.5) and shall conclude with reflections upon the prospective influence this decision may exert upon the trajectory of environmental jurisprudence and legislative development within Croatia (Chapter 4).
References
Blagojević A & Majnarić M (2023) The “Green” Constitution of the Republic of Croatia and the Constitutional Court as a Protector of the Right to a Healthy Environment, EU and Comparative Law Issues and Challenges Series (ECLIC), 7, pp. 33–55. https://doi.org/10.25234/eclic/27442.
Boyd D (2012) The Constitutional Right to a Healthy Environment, Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development, 54(4), pp. 3–15.
BVerfG, Beschluss des Ersten Senats vom 24. März 2021, 1 BvR 2656/18, Rn. 1-270, http://www.bverfg.de/e/rs20210324_1bvr265618.html [30.12.2023].
C-323/13 European Commission v Italian Republic, Judgment of 15 October 2014., ECLI:EU:C:2014:2290.
C-514/11 P and C-605/11 P AJ – LPN, Judgment of 14 November 2013, ECLI:EU:C:2013:738.
C-551/13 SETAR, Judgment of 18 December 2014, EU:C:2014:2467.
C-24/19 A and others, Judgment of 25 June 2020, ECLI:EU:C:2020:503.
C-315/20 Regione Veneto, Judgment of 11 November 2021, ECLI:EU:C:2021:912.
Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, OJ C 326, 26.10.2012.
Climate Change Adaptation Strategy in the Republic of Croatia for the Period Until 2040 With a View to 2070, OG no. 46/2020, https://mingor.gov.hr/ UserDocsImages/KLIMA/Climate%20change%20adaptation%20strategy.pdf [30.12.2023].
Constitution of the Republic of Croatia, OG no. 56/1990, 135/1997, 113/2000, 28/2001, 76/2010 and 5/2014, https://tinyurl.com/3cbdeyfx.
Constitutional Act on the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia, OG no. 99/1999, 29/2002 and 49/2002 (consolidated text), https://www.usud.hr/en/ constitutional-act .
Decision and Ruling, no. U-II-845/2019 and U-II-2160/2019 of 18 April 2023.
Decision on Amendments to the Decision on the Order and Dynamics of Landfill Closure, OG no. 120/23.
Decision on the Order and Dynamics of Landfill Closure, OG no. 3/19 and 17/19.
European Commission (2017 & 2019) EU Environmental Implementation Review Country Reports for Croatia, https://tinyurl.com/9ehepw25 [30.12.2023].
European Commission (2021) Infringement decisions, 21 November, https:// tinyurl.com/36vvfcpf [30.12.2023].
European Commission (2022) EU Environmental Implementation Review Country Reports for Croatia, https://tinyurl.com/2ydy2xnv [30.12.2023].
Hoge Raad, 20.12.2019., 19/00135, English translation of the judgment available at: https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/#!/details?id=ECLI:NL:HR:2019:2007 [30.12.2023].
Lewis B (2018) Environmental Human Rights and Climate Change: Current Status and Future Prospects, Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd, Singapore.
Ofak L (2021) The approach of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Croatia towards the protection of the right to a healthy environment, Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Law, 16(31), pp. 85–98, https://doi.org/10.21029/ JAEL.2021.31.85.
Orosz F, Suri N, Hrecska-Kovács R & Szőke P (2021), Constitutional protection of the environment with particular regard to the Hungarian, German, Italian and Belgian constitutional regulation, Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Law, 16(31), pp. 99–120, https://doi.org/10.21029/JAEL.2021.31.99.
Staničić F (2022) Croatia: Constitutional Protection of the Right to a Healthy Life – Do We Need More in Order to Safeguard the Environment and Future Generations?, in: Szilágyi J E (ed.) Constitutional Protection of the Environment and Future Generations Legislation and Practice in Certain Central European Countries, Miskolc – Budapest, CEA Publishing, pp. 127–160. https://doi. org/10.54237/profnet.2022.jeszcpefg.
Sustainable Waste Management Act, OG no. 94/13, 73/17, 14/19 and 98/19.
Szilágyi J E (2022) Constitutional Protection of the Environment and Future Generations in Certain Central European Countries, in: Szilágyi J E (ed.) Constitutional Protection of the Environment and Future Generations Legislation and Practice in Certain Central European Countries, Miskolc – Budapest, CEA Publishing, pp. 479–526. https://doi.org/10.54237/profnet.2022.jeszcpefg.
Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz and Others v. Switzerland, Application No.: 53600/20, Judgement of 9 April 2024.
Verfassungsgerichtshof, G 123/2023-12, 27. Juni 2023., https://tinyurl.com/ ye273h46 [30.12.2023].
Waste Management Act, no. 84/21.