Rest periods in the light of EU law

Keywords: working time directive, break, daily rest period, weekly rest period, autonomous worker

Abstract

Workers’ right to minimum rest periods are a particularly important rule of EU social law, as set out in Article 31(2) of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union. This study reviews the provisions on rest periods in EU law and how they have been interpreted by the Court of Justice of the European Union. After a general overview, the rules on the measure and schedule of rest periods are analysed, followed by an assessment of possible exceptions. The study then highlights three major problems of legal harmonisation in Hungarian law. First, the national rules on flexible working time schedule may be more realistic than the Court’s interpretation of the concept of autonomous worker, but there is still a conflict with EU law. Second, the possibility of extraordinary working time during the weekly rest period is liable to completely deprive the weekly rest period from its meaning, which should therefore be limited. Lastly, the rules on the aggregation of weekly rest periods are problematic not only because the working time directive and Hungarian law uses different terminology, but also because these rules allow continuous working without a rest day for very long periods.

References

Aharoni-Goldenberg, Sharona: Overtime: Re-Interpreting the opt-out derogation. European Labour Law Journal, Vol. 10., No. 1. (2019) https://doi.org/10.1177/2031952519828752

Bankó Zoltán – Berke Gyula – Kiss György – Szőke Gergely László: Nagykommentár a mun-ka törvénykönyvéről szóló 2012. évi I. törvényhez. uj.jogtar.hu, 2024.

Barnard, Catherine: Exceptional exceptions: The case of the Working Time Directive. Europe-an Labour Law Journal, Vol. 14., No. 1. (2023) https://doi.org/10.1177/20319525221141619

Bergen, C. W. Von, – Bressler, Martin S. – Proctor, Trevor L.: On the Grid 24/7/365 and the Right to Disconnect. Employee Relations Law Journal, Vol. 45., No. 2. (2019)

Bogg, Alan: Article 31: Fair and Just Working Conditions. In: Steve J. Peers- Tamara Hervey-Jeff Kenner- Angela Ward (szerk.): The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: a commentary. Oxford, Hart, 2014. https://doi.org/10.5771/9783845259055_876

Campbell, Iain: Working-time flexibility. Diversification and the rise of fragmented time systems. In: Damian Grimshaw – Colette Fagan – Gail Hebson – Isabel Tavora (szerk.): Ma-king work more equal. A new labour market segmentation approach. Manchester University Press, 2017. https://doi.org/10.7765/9781526125972.00013

Erikson, Merle: Introducing the autonomous employee category: The chance to create a flexible and secure employment relationship? European Labour Law Journal, Vol. 12., No. 3. (2021) https://doi.org/10.1177/2031952521990854

Goudswaard, Anneke et al.: Organisation of working time: Implications for productivity and working conditions. Overview Report. Eurofound, 2012.

Cabrita, Jorge – Cerf, Catherine: Rest breaks from work: Overview of regulations, research and practice, Luxembourg, Publications Office of the European Union, 2019.

Fodor T. Gábor – Tóth Kristóf: A négy hét, az négy hét – Gondolatok a szabadság munkaidő-keretben történő számításáról. Munkajog, 2021/3.

Fodor T. Gábor: A Munka Törvénykönyve munka- és pihenőidő szabályozásának uniós jogi megfelelőségéről. Magyar Munkajog E-folyóirat, hllj.hu, 2016/2.

Horváth István – Szladovnyik Krisztina: A Munka Törvénykönyve magyarázata. Budapest, Vezinfó, 2018.

Pál Lajos: A munka- és pihenőidő. In: Kardkovács Kolos (szerk.): A Munka Törvénykönyvének magyarázata. Budapest, HVG-ORAC, 2016.

Petrovics Zoltán: A munkafeltételek egységes szabályozása. In: Hungler Sára – Gellérné Lukács Éva – Petrovics Zoltán – Dudás Katalin: Az Európai Unió szociális- és munkajoga. Budapest, ELTE Eötvös, 2020.

Pisarczyk, Łukasz: Negotiating working time in times of crisis. Bulletin of comparative labour relations, Vol. 99. (2018).

Riesenhuber, Karl: European Employment Law: A Systemic Exposition. Intersentia, 2021

Risak, Martin: Working time. In: Monika Schlacter (szerk.): EU Labour Law: A Commentary. Wolters Kluwer, 2015.

Rose, Emily: Workplace Temporalities: A Time-Based Critique of the Flexible Working Provi-sions. Industrial Law Journal, Vol. 46., No. 2. (2017) https://doi.org/10.1093/indlaw/dww039

Sipka Péter –Zaccaria Márton Leó: A munkaidő uniós jogi fogalma: a készenlét teljes tartama munkaidőkénti minősítésének dilemmája. Munkajog, 2021

Szabó Mercédesz Ibolya: A munkaidő egyoldalú meghatározása a hatályos munkajogi szabá-lyozásban. Debreceni Jogi Műhely, 2021/1–2. https://doi.org/10.24169/DJM/2021/1-2/6

Takács Gábor: A munka- és pihenőidő. In: Gyulavári Tamás – Hős Nikolett – Kártyás Gábor – Takács Gábor: A Munka Törvénykönyve 2015, egységes szerkezetben állásfoglalásokkal és ma-gyarázatokkal. Budapest, Kompkonzult, 2015.

Zbyszewska, Ania: Reshaping EU working-time regulation: towards a more sustainable regime. European Labour Law Journal, Vol. 7., No. 3. (2016). https://doi.org/10.1177/201395251600700302

Published
2024-12-16
Section
Acta