Safeguarding the cultural patrimony of the Republic of Moldova
the involvement of civil society in protecting cultural heritage
Abstract
Civil society is one of the most important factors when it comes to cultural heritage management and protection. National and international organizations alike have a keen interest in preserving and protecting cultural heritage in the pursuit of historical continuity and community empowerment. The purpose of this paper is to analyse the tools and means through which the civil society involves itself in safeguarding cultural heritage in the Republic of Moldova. We follow the evolution of the civil society in the last 20 years, with an emphasis of legislative measures taken by authorities, and advocated by civil organizations, towards the protection and preservation of cultural heritage. The hypothesis we base our research on consists of the idea that the process of protecting cultural heritage is a complex and pervasive endeavour, and civil organizations, while having a big impact in constructing and implementing legislative and strategic documents, have little influence in the real act of safeguarding cultural heritage, in the absence of thorough collaboration with national and local authorities. From a methodological perspective, the research includes tools such as: literature review, document analysis, legal research and an overview of concrete actions conducted by civil society organizations in the Republic of Moldova, towards cultural heritage protection and promotion. The last offers an original perspective on civil society’s role in safeguarding cultural heritage, following three areas of action pertaining to cultural civil organizations: advocacy and policy making, education and raising awareness and research and development.
References
Association Council (2017): “The Recommendation no 1/2017 of the EU-Republic of Moldova Association Council on the EU-Republic of Moldova Association Agenda”, In: J.Of. nr. L 215/3/2017, available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:22017D1489, Accessed 10.01.2024.
Badman, Tim (2016): “Securing Civil Society’s Contribution to the World Heritage Convention”, In Doempke, Stephan (ed.) The UNESCO World Heritage and the Role of Civil Society. Proceedings of the International Conference, Bonn 2015, World Heritage Watch, Berlin.
Brânză, Sergiu – Stati, Vitalie (2016): “Protecția penală a patrimoniului cultural din perspectiva amendamentelor operate prin Legea nr. 75/ 2016” In: Studia Universitatis Moldaviae, 3, Social Sciences Series, pp. 12-25, ISSN 1814-31.
Brie, Mircea – Putină, Natalia (2023): “The development and role of civil society in the Republic of Moldova in the framework of the Eastern Partnership (2009-2021)” In: Civil Szemle, 2023/4, pp. 167-186, ISSN 1786-3341.
Budianschi, Dumitru – Stafii, Angela – Șonțu, Ghenadie – Reabcinsch, Veaceslav (2013): Evaluarea eficienței și transparenței utilizării resurselor publice alocate culturii, available at: https://www.expertgrup.org/media/k2/attachments/Evaluarea_eficientei_si-_transparentei_utilizarii_resurselor_publice_alocate_culturii.pdf, Accessed 10.01.2024.
Centrul Național Anticorupție (2021): Analiza strategică privind ameninţările de corupţie în activitatea Consiliului Naţional al Monumentelor Istorice în domeniul protejării de stat a monumentelor istorice, available at: https://www.cna.md/public/files/AS-protejare-monumente-istorice64dca.pdf, Accessed 10.01.2024.
Comisia Europeană (2023): Raport Alternativ Nr. 1: Realizarea Planului de Acțiuni pentru implementarea măsurilor propuse de Comisia Europeană privind cererea de aderare a Republicii Moldova la UE, 13.04.2023, available at: https://crjm.org/raport-alternativ-nr-1-realizarea-planului-de-actiuni-pentru-implementarea-masurilor-propuse-de-comisia-europeana-privind-cererea-de-aderare-a-republicii-moldova-la-ue/15620, Accessed: 11.01.2024.
Consiliul Europei (2012): Raport privind evaluarea situaţiei patrimoniului cultural 5-7 iunie 2012, available at: https://mecc.gov.md/sites/default/files/raport_misiune_de_experti_consiliul_-europei_evaluare_situatie_patrimoniu_cultural_in_moldova.pdf, Accessed 11.01.2024.
Conti, Alfredo (2016): “ICOMOS and the Civil Society: Constructing Bridges for a Common Work”, In: Doempke, Stephan (ed.) The UNESCO World Heritage and the Role of Civil Society. Proceedings of the International Conference, Bonn 2015, World Heritage Watch, Berlin.
Crăciunescu, Adrian (2016): “Codul patrimoniului cultural ca necesitate pentru România”, In: Musteață, Sergiu (ed.) Tendințe curente în protecția patromoniului arheologic în România și Republica Moldova, Chișinău: Arc, pp. 93-109, ISBN 978-9975-137-41-6.
Cukanova, Miroslava– Krnacova, Paulina (2018): “Impact of Cultural Heritage on Tourism.” In: Proceedings of 18th International Joint Conference Central and Eastern Europe in the Changing Business Environment, pp. 35-44, available at: https://of.euba.sk/www_write/files/veda-vyskum/publikacie/2018-5-25-proceedings-ceecbe-2018.pdf, Accessed 11.01.2024, ISSN 2453-6113.
Dobrea, Sergiu (2012): “Reflecții privind finanțarea instituțiilor muzeale în Republica Moldova”, In: Tyragetia (Serie Nouă), 2, pp. 393-396, available at: https://www.ceeol.com/search/viewpdf?id=516072, Accessed 22.01.2024.
De Cesari, Chiara (2020), “Heritage beyond the Nation-State?: Nongovernmental Organizations, Changing Cultural Policies, and the Discourse of Heritage as Development”, In: Current Anthropology 61(1), DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/707208.
Ghilaș, Victor (2019): “The axiological potential of cultural heritage”, In: Ghilaș, Victor, Dolghi, Adrian (ed.) Patrimoniul cultural național ca resursă pentru o dezvoltare durabilă a Republicii Moldova, 1, pp. 5-7.
Guvernul Republicii Moldova (2019): Proiectul de lege pentru modificarea Legii 58/20l2 privind рrоtеjаrеа patrimoniului cultural imaterial (The draft law for the amendment of Law 58/2012 on the transfer of intangible cultural heritage), available at: https://cancelaria.gov.md/sites/default/files/document/attachments/822.pdf, Accessed 10.01.2024.
Guvernul Republicii Moldova (2023): Proiectul de hotărâre a Parlamentului privind modificarea Registrului monumentelor Republicii Moldova ocrotite de stat (The draft decision of the Parliament regarding the modification of the Register of monuments of the Republic of Moldova protected by the state), available at: https://gov.md/sites/default/files/document/attachments/subiect-11-nu-135-2023.pdf, Accessed 11.01.2024.
Jitari, Liliana (2021): “General Evaluation of the Potential of the Cultural-Historical Heritage Built in the Republic of Moldova”, In: Open Journal of Applied Sciences, 11, pp. 633-646, available at: https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=110003, Accessed 10.01.2024.
Joldescu-Stan, Gianina (2023): “Economic Perspectives and The Role of Technology in Cultural Heritage Protection and Sustainable Development.” In: Online Journal Modelling the New Europe, 43: available at: http://neweurope.centre.ubbcluj.ro/?page_id=2493, Accessed 20.01.2024.
Lazăr, Augustin (2020): “Protecting the Cultural Heritage in the EU Judicial Space, Recognition of the fundamental right to culture” In: Miheș, Cristian Dumitru (ed) In honorem Valentin Mirişan. Gânduri, studii şi instituţii, Bucureşti: Universul Juridic, pp. 132-146.
Musteață, Sergiu (2007): “Preservation of the archaeological heritage in the Republic of Moldova” In: Archaeologisches Nachrichtenblatt, 12(4), pp. 311-325.
Musteață, Sergiu (2012): “A New Law- A New Perspective for Archaeological Heritage Preservation in the Republic of Moldova” In: International Journal of Cultural Property, 19(4), pp. 535-541.
Musteață, Sergiu (2016): “The Role of Civil Society in Archaeological Heritage Preservation in the Republic of Moldova” In: Sociology and Anthropology, 4 (10), pp. 910-914, available at: http://www.hrpub.org, Accessed 10.01.2024.
Musteață, Sergiu (2023): “Implementarea Convenției europene privind protecția patrimoniului arheologic (revizuită, Valetta, 1992) in Republica Moldova-realizări, probleme și perspective” In: Alămoreanu, Sorin– Predescu, Ovidiu– Duțu, Mircea (2023) Studii de drept al patrimoniului cultural și natural. Patrimonium. In Honorem Augustin Lazar, București: Universul juridic, pp. 112-129.
Pasat, Alexandru (2018): “Legal news on penal protection of cultural patrimony: the experience of the Republic of Moldova” In: Contemporary Challanges in Administrative Law and Public Administration, Adjuris Press, pp. 218-229.
Postică, Gheorghe (2016): “Legislația patrimoniului cultural din Republica Moldova: tendințe și practici contemporane” In: Musteață, Sergiu (ed.) Tendințe curente în protecția patromoniului arheologic în România și Republica Moldova, Chișinău: Arc, pp. 47-54.
Proceedings of 18th International Joint Conference: Central and Eastern Europe in the Changing Business Environment: available at: https://www.webofscience.com/wos/woscc/full-record/WOS:000455322400004, Accessed 21.01.2024
Putină, Natalia – Brie, Mircea (2023): “Civil Society Development and Democratization in the Republic of Moldova” In: Civil Szemle, 2023/4, pp. 79-108.
Quaedvlieg-Mihailović, Sneška (2016): “Towards a Global Civil Society Alliance for Heritage”, In: Doempke, Stephan (ed.) The UNESCO World Heritage and the Role of Civil Society. Proceedings of the International Conference, Bonn 2015, World Heritage Watch, Berlin.
Rusanovschi, Iulian (2018): Razboiul Monumentelor. Soarta monumentelor din Basarabia, Bucovina de Nord si Transnistria din perioada 1918-1944, Chișinău: Cu Drag Publishing.
Rusanovschi, Iulian (2022): Războiul monumentelor. Restabilirea monumentelor românești din Republica Moldova. 2010-2022, București: UZP Press.
SAVE Chisinău (2023): Poveștile Nespuse ale Orașului (The Untold Stories of the City): available at: https://savechisinau.org/promovam-frumos-cladirile-istorice-ale/, Accessed 20.01.2024.
SAVE Chișinău (2021): Modificările la Legea Ocrotirii Monumentelor, votate în Parlament (Amendments to the Law on the Protection of Monuments, voted in Parliament), available at: https://savechisinau.org/modificarile-la-legea-ocrotirii-monumentelor-votate-in-parlament/, Accessed 12.01.2024.
The Ministry of Culture of the Republic of Moldova (2023): Codul Vizual privind Amplasarea Firmelor și a Publicității Exterioare, supus consultărilor publice (The Visual Code regarding the Location of Companies and Outdoor Advertising, subject to public consultations), available at: https://mc.gov.md/ro/content/codul-vizual-privind-amplasarea-firmelor-si-publicitatii-exterioare-supus-consultarilor, Accessed 12.01.2024.
The Parliament of the Republic of Moldova (2023): Proiectul de lege pentru modificarea Legii culturii nr. 413/1999.art.10, 21 (The draft law for the amendment of the Culture Law no. 413/1999, art. 10, 21), available at: https://shorturl.at/cjT69, Accessed 12.01.2024.
Throsby, David (1999): “Cultural Capital”. In: Journal of Cultural Economics, 23 (1/2), pp. 3-12.
Twinning Project (2019): Introductory report -key elements for an inter– sectorial approach to cultural heritage promotion, available at: https://mecc.gov.md/sites/default/files/01_tw_md_introductory_report_-intercomponent_update_ago_2019.pdf, Accessed 22.01.2024.
