The Republic of Moldova's civil society and democratic resilience in the context of the EU integration process
Abstract
The present study intends to explore both the shortcomings and the achievements of the Republic of Moldova in the fields of civil society and democratic resilience in the context of EU accession process. The first hypothesis of the study asserts that there is a strong correlation between the evolution of Republic of Moldova’s civil society and the democratization of the state. A more specific hypothesis of the study investigates the impact of EU’s support and recommendations for strengthening the sustainability of democracy and civil society. The first hypothesis is discussed in the first two sections of the present study. The investigation of the second hypothesis forms the content of the next two sections, as follows: section three of the study consists in the interpretative analysis of the last three European Action Plans (EUAP) in order to assess the impact of EU’s incentives and conditionalities for the consolidation of democracy and the enhancement of civil society in Moldova; section four of the study focuses on exploring the transformative role of the EU regarding Moldova’s civil society and democratic consolidation in the framework of the Eastern Partnership (EaP). A concluding section reflects upon the main gaps between the EU’s norms and values and the Moldovan civil society and democratic occurrences, respectively, and inquires on the EU’s strategic switch from democratic to geopolitical resilience. Methodologically, the study utilizes qualitative research instruments (descriptive and interpretative content analysis) and data collected on reports of implementation of EUAPs and EaP agendas, recommendations concerning the implementation of policies and reforms, second data extracted from scientific literature on the subject.
References
Akhvlediani, Tinatin (2022): Geopolitical and Security Concerns of the EU’s Enlargement to the East: The Case of Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia. Intereconomics, 57 (4): 225-228.
Badescu, Gabriel – Sum, Paul-Uslaner, Eric M. (2004): Civil Society Development and Democratic Values in Romania and Moldova. East European Politics and Societies, 18 (2): 1-26.
Baltag, Dorina – Burmester, Isabell (2022): Quo Vadis, Moldova? The Role of Social and Political Elites in the Norm Internalization Process. Democratization, 29 (3): 487-506.
Balutel, Adrian (2019): The Civil Society Landscape in the Republic of Moldova. Politik Aktuell, 2: 1-6.
Boese, Vanessa A. – Edgell, Amanda B. – Hellmeier, Sebastian – Maerz, Seraphine F. – Lindberg, Staffan I. (2021): How Democracies Prevail: Democratic Resilience as a Two-stage Process. Democratization, 28 (5): 885–907.
Borza, Sorin-Gelu (2022): The European Way of Thinking and the Crisis of Democratic Practices Within Procedural Societies. Civil Szemle, 2022/3: 5-18.
Boulègue, Mathieu – Lutsevych, Orysia – Marin, Anaïs (2018): Civil Society Under Russia’s Threat: Building Resilience in Ukraine, Belarus and Moldova. Russia and Eurasia Programme, Chatham House: The Royal Institute of International Affairs, 1-44.
Brie, Mircea – Putină, Natalia (2023): The Development and Role of Civil Society in the Republic of Moldova in the Framework of the Eastern Partnership. Civil Szemle, 2023/4: 167-185.
Całus, Kamil (2015): A Captured State? Moldova’s Uncertain Prospects for Modernisation. OSW Commentary 168, Warsaw: Centre for Eastern Studies, 1-9.
Cenușa, Denis (2019): EU Policy on Strengthening Resilience in Moldova, Ukraine and Georgia Between the Rule of Law and Oligarchic Influence. CEPS Paper in Liberty and Security in Europe 2. Brussels, 1-13.
Chiriac, Liubomir – Țugui, Eduard (2014): Civil Society Organizations from the Republic of Moldova: Development, Sustainability and Participation in Policy Dialogue. Mapping Study, Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, 1-62.
Corpădean, Adrian-Gabriel (2023): Some Considerations on the Usefulness of the EU Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance III for Fostering Conflict Resolution in the Western Balkans. Civil Szemle, ,2023/2: 39-51.
Council of Europe (2013): Action Plan to Support Democratic Reforms in the Republic of Moldova 2013-2016. ODGProg/Inf(2013)17 final. 15 November.
Council of Europe (2017): Action Plan for the Republic of Moldova 2017-2020. GR-DEM(2017)3. 17 January.
Council of Europe (2020): Action Plan for the Republic of Moldova 2021-2024. CM(2020)161. 19 November.
Crowther, William (2023): Moldova’s First Quarter Century: Flawed Transition and Failed Democracy. Nationalities Papers, 51 (1): 33-46.
Dahrendorf, Ralf (1990): Reflections on the Revolutions in Europe. New York: Random House.
Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum (2017): Eastern Partnership Index 2015-2016: Charting Progress in European Integration, Democratic Reforms, and Sustainable Development.
Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum (2023): Cooperation, Security and Democracy: Making a Multi-speed Eastern Partnership Work. Resolution of the General Assembly of the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum, Brussels, 1-8.
Economist Intelligence (2022): Democracy Index 2021: The China Challenge.
European Commission (2022): Commission Opinion on the Republic of Moldova’s Application for Membership of the European Union. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the European Council and the Council. Brussels, 1-25.
Groza, Iulian (2019): Moldova: Renewed Hopes after a String of Setbacks. IN The Eastern Partnership a Decade On: Looking Back, Thinking Ahead. European Union Institute for Security Studies EUISS, 42-56.
Howard, Marc Morjé (2002): The Weakness of Civil Society in Post-Communist Europe. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Hummel, Siri (2020): The Contested Spaces of Civil Society – On the Paradox of Shrinking and Growing in Civil Society’s Sphere of Action. Civil Szemle, 2020/4: 55-71.
Knott, Eleanor (2018): Perpetually ‘Partly Free’: Lessons from Post-Soviet Hybrid Regimes on Backsliding in Central and Eastern Europe. East European Politics, 34 (3): 355–376.
Lührmann, Anna (2021): Disrupting the Autocratization Sequence: Towards Democratic Resilience. Democratization, 28 (5): 1017-1039.
Lynch, Dov (2005): The security Dimension of the European Neighbourhood Policy. The International Spectator, 40 (1): 33-43.
Marandici, Ion (2021): Taming the Oligarchs? Democratization and State Capture: The Case of Moldova. Demokratizatsiya, 29 (1): 63–89.
Merkel, Wolfgang (2023): What Is Democratic Resilience and How Can We Strengthen It? Policy Brief no. 169, Toda Peace Institute, 1-15.
Mikulova, Kristina (2014): Potemkin Europeanisation? Dynamics of Party Competition in Poland and Hungary in 1998-2004. East European Politics and Societies, 28 (1): 163-186.
Minzarari, Dumitru (2022): Justice Reform as the Battleground for Genuine Democratic Transformation in Moldova: Insights for the Eastern Partnership. SWP Comment no. 27, Berlin: Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik (SWP), 1-8.
Pavliuc, Cristina – Buga, Alexandru (2022): Democracy and Economic Growth: The Case of Moldova. Journal of Social Sciences, V (3): 71-87.
Plasser, Fritz – Ulram, Peter A. – Waldrauch, Harald (1998): Democratic Consolidation in East-Central Europe. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
Popșoi, Mihail (2021): Europeanization versus Democratization in Georgia, Moldova and Ukraine: Internal and External Challenges to Democratic Consolidation. Doctoral Thesis. Universita' degli Studi di Milano.
Putină, Natalia – Brie, Mircea (2023): Civil Society Development and Democratization in the Republic of Moldova. Civil Szemle, 2023/4: 79-107.
Quinlan, Paul (2004): Back to the Future: An Overview of Moldova under Voronin. Demokratizatsiya, 12 (4): 485-504.
Rinnert, David (2013): The Republic of Moldova in the Eastern Partnership: From ‘Poster Child’ to ‘Problem Child’? Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, 1-9.
Taylor, Charles S. (1990): Modes of Civil Society. Public Culture, 3 (1): 95-118.
Way, Lucan (2003): Weak States and Pluralism: The Case of Moldova. East European Politics and Societies, 17 (3): 454–482.
